This page shows the Pony Surprise mommy plush released by the toy line Just Play. They could come with three, four, or five babies tucked in their tummy pouches (putting the surprise in “Pony Surprise”). We call later releases “Pony No Surprise” because as the line progressed, the advertised odds of getting more than three babies went way down, and frankly the real odds come out even worse than the bad ones admitted to.
The Pony Surprise moms all share a face mold (an original Hasbro one) except Licorice. Don’t let that fool you though, they aren’t all ponies. There are some wings and horns thrown into the mix to keep things interesting. Unicorns and Pegasus… completely different beasts.
Each mom’s page will show her and her five babies. To view other types of Just Play Surprise Pets, click here.
Hey Internet! Looking for Pony Surprise? I’ve got the search all set up for you on:
Toysisters is ad-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission (at no cost to you), which helps to keep the site online and updating. Thanks!
Aaaaand, also here:
Toysisters is ad-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission (at no cost to you), which helps to keep the site online and updating. Thanks!